This no-churn, extra-creamy peanut butter ice cream will make an ideal treat for a sunny day. Full of rich, nutty flavour with a hint of buttery caramel from Lyle's Golden Syrup. It takes 10 minutes to make and you don't need an ice-cream machine or any fancy equipment to make them!
It's made with only a handful of ingredients, and unlike many recipes out there, this one doesn't require any condensed milk or bananas! If frozen desserts are your thing, then you are going to love this ice cream!
This post is sponsored by Lyle's Golden Syrup but all thoughts and opinions are my own. Thank you for supporting the brands that make Anna Banana possible!
Why you would love this recipe
Peanut butter is one of my all-time favourite ingredients and this ice cream recipe is bursting with that very flavour. The richness of thick and creamy peanut butter combined with mild, buttery and almost caramel-like golden syrup creates match made in heaven!
It's a no-churn recipe, meaning that you do not require an ice cream machine or an ice cream maker. Unlike many homemade peanut butter ice cream recipes out there, this one doesn't use sweetened condensed milk. Instead, this ice cream is made using golden syrup.
If you love peanut butter as much as I do, make sure to check out my other recipes, like these 3-ingredient peanut butter energy bites or chocolate brownies with peanut butter frosting.
As mentioned above, there is only a handful of ingredients needed to make this peanut butter flavor ice cream. Let's have a closer look at them:
- Egg yolks - 4 large egg yolks are needed in this recipe. The egg yolks add richness to the texture and also leverage the fat already present in the ice cream base (the butterfat in the double cream) and make it into an even creamier texture.
- Lyle's Golden Syrup - The secret weapon of this recipe! Used instead of sugar, this delicious and versatile baking ingredient adds body, creaminess and stability to your ice cream. It also creates an additional depth of flavour, adding these buttery, caramel notes.
- Double/ heavy cream - The base of most of ice creams (often used together with whole milk). The fat in cream contributes to several important roles in ice cream. It provides smooth and creamy texture, it adds its own flavor and it helps to make the ice cream creamier. It also slows down the melting, by stabilising the air bubbles. Double/ heavy cream will work best, due to its higher fat content. Ice cream made with higher fat will be richer and creamier with a long aftertaste.
- Peanut butter - Not only it adds the main flavour to this recipe, but it also adds more fat. As we discovered above, the higher the fat content, the creamier and more stabilised your ice cream will be. You can use smooth or crunchy peanut butter. Homemade peanut butter will be even better!
- Vanilla extract - Optional, but a dash of vanilla adds a subtle flavour and enhances the peanut butter flavour even more.
If you are planning on making your own peanut butter ice cream, I would recommend to start a day ahead. The ice cream will need a minimum of 6 hours in the freezer, or ideally an overnight freeze.
If you would like, you can watch this video on my Instagram Reels to see how easy it is to make this ice cream.
Start by whisking the egg yolks for 2-3 minutes until they are pale and fluffy. Once done, add Lyle's Golden Syrup and whisk both again.
Pour in the double cream into egg yolks mixture and beat all the ingredients together. Place the bowl with the egg yolk and cream mixture over the saucepan with simmering water. Continue to whisk for 5 minutes, until it becomes frothy and bubbly.
You know the mixture is ready, when it coats the back of the spoon or spatula. You are looking for a thin custard consistency. Remove the bowl from the saucepan and set it aside, allowing the mixture to cool just a little.
Stir in the melted peanut butter and whisk all of the ingredients once more, until you have a thick and creamy mixture. Pour it into a freezer-friendly container and tap it against the surface a few times, to release the air bubbles.
Allow the mixture to cool completely. Cover the top with cling film and transfer to the freezer for minimum of 6 hours or for an overnight freeze.
Optional extras and serving suggestions
This ice cream already tastes great on its own, but you can also try experimenting with lots of add-ons and different serving suggestions.
- Reserve some of the peanut butter and add a peanut butter swirl into your ice cream. When pouring the ice cream into the container, pour half of the mixture in, then swirl the peanut butter layer and finish by pouring the remaining ice cream mixture on top.
- Add chopped, roasted peanuts into the ice cream mix, or serve scoops of ice cream with a sprinkle of roasted, chopped peanuts on top.
- Enhance the peanut butter flavour by adding some mini peanut butter cups into the ice cream mix before freezing it.
- Why not try adding some sea salt flakes? Adding a sprinkle of sea salt flakes on top of your ice cream will enhance that peanut butter flavour even more!
- Drizzle some melted chocolate or Lyle's Golden Syrup on top for an even more delicious ice cream.
Homemade ice cream is best eaten fresh. The fresher, the better! I would recommend eating your ice cream within two weeks of making it.
Because it doesn't contain any chemicals or preservatives, which will keep it for longer, you want to eat it as soon as possible for the best and the freshest flavour.
The optimum storing temperature for ice cream is -18° C (0°F) or lower.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an ice cream machine to make this recipe?
No! The beauty of this peanut butter ice cream is the fact that it doesn't require an ice cream maker/ machine. It is a no-churn ice cream, you just make it and allow it to freeze. You don't even have to do any stirring or mixing it in between!
What can I use to freeze my ice cream in?
There are few different ways that you can store and freeze your ice cream in. My personal favourite is to use a loaf pan. Most kitchens will already have one, and it fits easily in the freezer. Metal or glass pans will be fine to use.
If you don't have a loaf pan, you can also use an old (used) ice cream container. Just make sure you wash it before using it.
You can also purchase a special ice cream containers in speciality stores or online. But any freezer-friendly container can be used, just make sure you check it is suitable for freezing.
Can I refreeze partially melted ice cream?
In simplest terms- no, you can't. This is because ice crystals will form on your ice cream if you refreeze it. This will impact the texture of your ice cream in a negative way. I would recommend freezing your ice cream as soon as you have finished serving it, to minimise the ice crystals developing.
If you tried this Peanut Butter Ice Cream or any other of my recipes, feel free to leave me a comment and a rating below. I love hearing from you!
To pin this recipe and save it for later, use the button on the recipe card or on any of the photos above.
Peanut Butter Ice Cream
- hand-held electric mixer or whisk
- mixing bowl
- medium saucepan
- 1 lb loaf tin or freezer-friendly container of similar capacity
- 4 large egg yolks
- 120 ml Lyle's Golden Syrup
- 500 ml double/ heavy cream
- 200 g smooth or crunchy peanut butter melted/ spreadable consistency
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- Place the egg yolks into a large bowl and using an electric mixer or whisk, beat them until pale and fluffy, about 2-3 minutes. Add Lyle's Golden Syrup and whisk again to combine. Pour in the double/ heavy cream and mix it all together.
- Bring a medium saucepan set over medium heat to simmer, then place the bowl with the egg yolk mixture on top of it, ensuring that the bottom of the bowl doesn't touch the water. Keep whisking the mixture for 5-10 minutes until it becomes really frothy and bubbly. You know the mixture is ready, when it coats the back of the spoon. Remove from the heat and allow it to cool slightly.
- Stir in the melted peanut butter into the egg yolk mixture, followed by vanilla extract and whisk well to combine. Pour the mixture into a freezer-friendly container, then tap it few times against the surface to release the air bubbles. Allow it to cool completely, then cover the top with clingfilm and place in the freezer for minimum of 6 hours or overnight.
- Remove the ice cream from the freezer about 15 minutes before serving, scoop & enjoy!
Please note that all my recipes are developed and tested in metric grams. I recommend that you use digital scales for a more accurate results. I have provided a conversion to US customary in the recipe but please note that I haven’t tested using this method.
- This homemade peanut butter ice cream is best eaten fresh. Consume it within two weeks of making it.
- The optimum storing temperature for the ice cream is -18°C (0°F) or lower.
- You can use a loaf pan, an old ice cream container, or any freezer- friendly container to store your ice cream in.
- Once defrosted, do not re-freeze your ice cream.
I've never used Lyle's syrup in ice cream but love it on pancakes! This peanut butter ice cream looks so so good. On my to try list!
I couldn’t resist the recipe knowing I had golden syrup and peanut butter in my pantry. I made this ice cream yesterday…SO GOOD. My whole family loved it. Thank you for such a delicious recipe!
Hi Natalia, thanks so much for this lovely feedback, so glad that you and your family enjoyed it!
These are two of my favorite things combined into one! My most favorite part (besides eating it) is that I don't have to have an ice cream maker to make it. Bonus points!
This is such a delicious and simple recipe! I have to make it for my hubby, he LOVES peanut butter!
Thanks Veronika, I hope he will enjoy this ice cream as much as I do!
I'd never made proper ice cream before but it was actually easier than I thought it would be! This ice cream was a hit.
Thanks so much for this lovely feedback Veronika, I'm so happy to hear that!
I could enjoy this recipe over and over again... There is just nothing better than a big-big ice cream on a hot summer day. Yum!
Wow! i never thought to use Lyle's in ice cream. I bet it is delicious! My family are huge peanut butter fans so they loved this rich and creamy treat.
Lyle's syrup is such a game changer in homemade ice cream recipes, I hope you will try it some time soon Bernice!
Would this work with almond butter?
Hi Nuzi, I haven't tried this recipe with any other nut butter, but I would love to know the results if you make it using the almond butter!
I made it with almond butter (due to unfortunate allergies in the family) and it is absolutely delicious 😋!!!! So creamy and rich.
Will definitely be making this again 😃
Hi Nuzi! That is so great to hear that it works with almond butter too, I'm sure other readers will find this info helpful! I'm so happy to hear that you enjoyed this recipe, and thanks so much for taking time to leave the review and the comment! Much appreciated x